top of page

Debunking AI Hype and Navigating Ethical Waters: Google's Gemini Controversy and the EU's AI Act

In the dynamic realm of artificial intelligence, the spotlight often shines on the latest breakthroughs and pioneering technologies. Google has once again grabbed attention with their newest addition to the AI landscape, the Gemini AI model. This isn't just another step in machine learning—it's an assertion of creating their most extensive and advanced AI model to date. However, significant innovations like this are often met with scrutiny. The unveiling of Gemini AI was met with a mix of admiration and criticism. Critics pointed out that a video released by Google, showcasing Gemini's proficiency in understanding spoken language and visual imagery, was not a real-time demonstration. The video description revealed minimized latency and abbreviated outputs for demonstration purposes. Observers discovered that researchers had supplied the model with pre-written text prompts and static images, raising questions about the authenticity of the AI's capabilities. Google later admitted that the video was an "illustrative depiction of the possibilities" of interacting with Gemini, based on actual test results. This skepticism mirrored the response to Google's Duplex Demo, which also left viewers questioning the authenticity of an AI assistant's abilities. Investment strategies in AI are shifting as companies aim to seize opportunities in this field. Qualcomm is making a play for generative AI with the launch of the Snapdragon X Elite, promising AI processing speeds that outpace rivals. Alphabet, Google's parent company, has seen its stock rise thanks to increased advertising revenue and ambitious strides in the cloud and AI sectors. Microsoft, another giant known for its enduring software, is making its mark in the cloud and AI markets with a 24% year-on-year revenue increase in their Azure cloud platform. Despite controversies and authenticity challenges in AI demonstrations, the competition in artificial intelligence technology continues. As AI professionals and enthusiasts, our duty is to advocate for transparency and truth as much as for progress and breakthroughs. In a significant development in AI regulation, the European Parliament and Council negotiators announced a provisional agreement on the Artificial Intelligence Act, the world's first comprehensive legislation on AI. This act is set to become the blueprint for how AI interacts with our fundamental rights and freedoms, focusing on high-risk systems that could severely impact EU citizens. It mandates compulsory fundamental rights impact assessments for systems that could influence elections, banking, and insurance. The EU AI Act emphasizes transparency and legal obligations for AI systems that affect individuals' lives. It introduces an era of 'explainable AI,' demanding accountability and trust through required technical documentation, compliance with EU copyright law, and transparency about the data driving AI learning. The Act also takes a strong stance against unrestricted biometric identification, banning AI systems from using characteristics like race, political views, or sexual orientation to categorize individuals. It prohibits the indiscriminate collection of images for facial recognition databases and emotionally manipulative AI in workplaces and schools, signaling the importance of the human element in the human-AI relationship. With severe penalties for non-compliance, the Act underscores the EU's commitment to AI responsibility. However, there are concerns about the Act's future-proofing given the rapid evolution of AI. The legislation is seen as a framework that fortifies individual freedom and guards against systemic risks from AI. The EU AI Act is a landmark initiative that strikes a balance between technological advancement and commitment to individual rights and ethical standards. It is a precedent that could dictate global AI policy in the years to come, heralding a new era of responsible innovation for AI professionals and enthusiasts. Links:

1 view

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page